Key West Key Lime Pie Company is located in Key West. Before you head to Key West, plan trip itinerary details with our user-friendly Key West online trip planner , to make sure you see all that Key West has to offer, including Key West Key Lime Pie Company.
Key West Key Lime Pie Company Reviews
Shared a single slice. Overall good, tart key lime taste. However, both of us noticed the pie flavor left a slight aspartame/saccharin taste, even though the whipped creme tempered it a bit. Probably.... more »
Really good I thought. A little busy, price reaonable. Sadly the pie a little frozen still. We asked for the Extra tart piece of pie. They had a hard time finding that pie. I enjoyed it. I would..... more »
Every bit of DELICIOUS... I dropped in last night after reading the rave reviews. There are several places in Key West to claim they have the best pie but this place gets the gold medal. The pie was a perfect balance of tart and sweet. I wish I had purchased a whole pie to take back to the hotel. If key lime isn't your thing, they also serve ice cream in different flavors. Try the lime-aide, its more refreshing than water! Craig is a comedian and gave me stellar service. He allowed me to sample a combination of the mango and key lime together. What a treat! Do not be fooled by other key lime pie restaurants in the area, it's hard to keep up because a lot of the names are very similar. Review stops here, make your way to this pie shop. You won't be sorry! Signed, Florida native
Not the best I've had... the whipped cream was okay as well. It was good, don't get me wrong. However, I have waited 2 years to try it and I've actually had a lot better key lime pie.
Places to stay near Key West Key Lime Pie Company
Plan your trip to Key West
Get a personalized planA complete day-by-day itinerary
based on your preferences
Customize itRefine your plan. We'll find the
best routes and schedules
Book itChoose from the best hotels
and activities. Up to 50% off
Manage itEverything in one place.
Everyone on the same page.
View all ›
Side trips from Key West
Hidden gems in Key West
View all ›
View all ›
Nearby attractions in Key West
Plans in Key West by other users
6 days in East Coast of USA BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES April, hidden gems PREFERENCES: April ATTRACTION STYLE: Hidden gems PACE: Medium 26 days in Florida BY A USER FROM UNITED KINGDOM July, teens, popular sights PREFERENCES: July, teens ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular sights PACE: Medium 26 days in Florida BY A USER FROM UNITED KINGDOM July, teens, popular sights PREFERENCES: July, teens ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular sights PACE: Medium 26 days in United States BY A USER FROM INDIA March, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, shopping, slow & easy, popular & hidden gems PREFERENCES: March, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, shopping ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular & hidden gems PACE: Slow & easy 19 days in East Coast of USA BY A USER FROM ISRAEL April, kids, outdoors, historic sites, shopping, slow & easy, popular sights PREFERENCES: April, kids, outdoors, historic sites, shopping ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular sights PACE: Slow & easy 35 days in United States BY A USER FROM AUSTRALIA September, kids, popular & hidden gems PREFERENCES: September, kids ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular & hidden gems PACE: Medium